Buckeyes Ah, Buckeyes. What can I say about these? I haven't included them with the 'big three' of chocolate chip, peanut butter blossoms, and snickerdoodles, mainly because they're in a class by themselves. Though only moderately popular for the first 11 months of the year, these are by far and away the most popular at Christmas time. I sometimes think I could sell just Buckeyes at Christmas and still do alright! If you've never had these, imagine a Reeses Cup that looks like a Buckeye. Even though mine are priced at less than half of what you'll pay at most candy stores, once you try mine you'll never want anyone else's.